Mazel Tov
My grandparents are the first ones to arrive. They sit in the second row of
an empty synagogue because there is “no way they would be late for this
special milestone.” I don’t think I’ve ever seen my grandfather this
happy. His eyes dance around the room with delight and a smile spreads
across his face while he anxiously shakes his leg up and down, hands clasped
in his lap.
“Are you nervous?” my rabbi asks me.
I sigh and give a polite laugh. “Yeah.”
“Well, you don’t look nervous.” He puts his fleshy, calloused hands on my
shoulders. “You should be proud of yourself, Hanna.” For the first time
that I can remember, he pronounces my name correctly. “Today, you will
become an adult in the Jewish community.”
I slowly lift the ends of my lips upward and nod my head.
An hour later, I am sitting on an uncomfortable wooden chair on the stage—my
back abnormally upright. My hands trace the intricate wooden carvings on
the arm rests. I watch people slowly file in. The boys are dressed in
stiff, crisp suits and the girls in snug blouses and dresses. My mom and
aunt each support an arm of my great aunt as she slowly inches to her seat.
My parents’ friend laughs obnoxiously. I never liked that guy. My friends
cluster together and giggle. I wish I were laughing with them. I see some
complete strangers. My stomach is clenching tighter and tighter and—oh,
crap. What if I trip on stage or drop the Torah? What if I can’t remember
the Torah portion I am supposed to have memorized? What if I get the
hiccups in the middle of singing? Maybe I’ll just subtly leave the
building. Quietly leave through the back door and not come back. The rabbi
would simply have to carry on the service without me. But fuck. No. I can’t
leave now. It’s not okay to ditch your own Bat Mitzvah, right? No. Think
of how embarrassed my family would be. My proud and teary-eyed family. My
dad already has the tissue box out and ready. What a waste if I left now,
after years of learning Hebrew and singing prayers and practicing my speech
and choosing the colors of the cups and tablecloths and flowers and
napkins.
“Why don’t we get started,” the rabbi says in his slow, Hungarian accent.
“Shabbat Shalom.” The words hang in the air of the echoing room for a few
moments. “Today we would like to call Hanna to the Torah as a Bat
Mitzvah.” My rabbi turns around from the podium and signals me to come. I
cautiously walk in my high heels to the front of the stage. Left foot.
Right foot. Left foot. Right foot. Not going to trip. I get to the
microphone and look out into the audience. The risen sun has lighted up the
greens and blues of the stained-glass windows. I see my mom’s smile and my
dad’s playful, goofy expression. My brother’s eyes are glazed over
already. I have trouble focusing and all of the faces start to blend
together.
I place my finger below the Hebrew writing in the prayer book and begin to
chant the prayer. Lecha dodi likrat kalah. The sound of my own voice
echoing throughout the temple sounds strange. I don’t feel like it’s me
singing. The voice is chanting in a foreign language.. The prayers have
wholesome melodies but empty meanings. I have no idea what I am saying in
Hebrew. Nonetheless, I carry on the service. More reading Hebrew.
Carrying the Torah (And no—thank God—I do not drop it). More singing.
Reading English text (I say one line from the prayer book, then the audience
monotonously and robotically reads a line back to me. I almost start
laughing—everyone sounds like they’re dead). More chanting. Giving
speech. Parents saying how proud they are of me. Rabbi saying how proud he
is of me. Closing song. Done.
Once my friends and family leave the room, I take three steps off of the
stage to the wooden floor. I can finally breathe and smile; I can
experience, instead of imagine, the moment when This Would All Be Over. I
walk with my chin up and enjoy the scene around me and the present moment.
As I start to mingle through Mazeltovs and Youweresogreats and
Youshouldbesoproudofyourselfs, I come upon my great uncle, David. “Really
great job, Hanna,” he says with a grin, and pats my back. I give a wide,
smile back to him. I can relax and be happy now. “So—be honest,” David
begins, “are you happy you had a Bat Mitzvah?”
Before I think about what he is really asking, I say, “ Yeah, I am,”
like I’m expected to. My genuine happiness about the fact that I am done
shines through as sincerity in my response. His eyes twinkle; his heart is
delighted.
I walk outside to an overcast day and a brick courtyard. Tables are filled
with platters of mini bagels, lox, fruit, hummus and pita bread. The
platter of garbanzo bean dip is surfaced with eggplant skin cut into spiral
patterns, and sprinkled with red paprika. Uncle David’s words begin to echo
in my ear. Are you happy you had a Bat Mitzvah? Are you happy? I can feel
the anticipation of when this day is over, but not the least bit of
accomplishment or satisfaction. Why am I even here? Why is everyone so
proud of me? Suddenly, I feel butterflies in my stomach, but they are
pricking at my insides and make me want to punch someone. I didn’t even
know what I was saying in Hebrew. I am having a Bat Mitzvah because I’m a
Jew…but what does that even mean? Heat is rising through my veins. I just
want this day to be over. The feeling of invincibility at being almost done
with this day is put to a halt and I just feel frustrated. Am I Jewish
because I celebrate Chanukah? Because I go to religious school every
Tuesday and Thursday? I don’t even believe in God. I don’t even believe in
the Torah. People make up stories and myths all the time and people don’t
start worshipping them and living their life by what these books say. Why
is the Torah any different? Why am I here?
***
I am seven years old and it’s lunchtime at my elementary school. I sit on
the edge of a wooden flower box with my friend, Maya. One of my hands draws
spiral patterns in the dust on the ground, the other holds a stick of
celery. In the midst of silence, Maya turns her head to ask me something.
“Do you believe in God?”
I stop chewing for a moment. I’m not sure what led her to ask this
question. Do I believe in God? In my mind, I see an image of a man made
out of clouds, sitting in a golden throne outside of his castle, using a
feather and ink to write a book labeled “The Torah.” What’s the right
answer to this question? Is this a test? I know that we are both Jewish and
that Jews are supposed to believe in God. There is a 50% chance that “Yes”
is the answer she wants to hear. I go for it.
“Yeah, I do,” I say. My voice gets a little higher at the end of this
statement, almost as if I’m asking a question.
“Good—me too,” she quickly adds.
I feel a wave of relief that I picked the right answer.
***
I tune myself back into the scene of my Bat Mitzvah. I pose for a picture.
Shake hands. Make small talk. Say the blessing over the bread and wine.
The anger stirs inside my body. Did I really just have a Bat Mitzvah—and
practice Judaism my whole life—without even knowing why? The fire starts in
the center of my chest, then diffuses to the joints in my legs and fingers,
making them throb. I want to flex every muscle in my body to release the
tension. Did I choose to be a Jew simply because it was easier to be one,
than feel ashamed and distant from my family and friends for not being one?
I am so ready to get out of here. I no longer want to waste my time doing
things I don’t see the logic in, nor enjoy doing.
Once the platters of food are empty and the last thankyouforcoming is
said, I walk down the stairs with my friend, Rachel—ahead of my parents—to
exit the temple. Before opening the heavy gate to leave, I stop walking.
She stops to wait. I stand for a moment, looking down the
fluorescent-lighted hallway of classrooms and offices. A roll of balloon
stickers shines from the shelf. Twenty-five cents for five stickers.
During my five years of religious school here, my friends and I continuously
toyed with the concept of taking one of these stickers without paying.
There was nothing physically stopping you from doing so. The idea had
always been tempting, but our consciences prevented us from actually doing
it. I no longer feel this guilt as I slowly walk over to the roll of
stickers, and tear off a square of shiny balloon and confetti stickers. I
look at the colorful balloons for a moment, then crush the wax paper in my
fist and continue walking. The heavy, metal doors lock behind me.